A routine thrift store visit turned into an incredible windfall when a rare 1999-P Susan B. Anthony (SBA) Dollar surfaced and later sold for $4,200.
While most SBA dollars are worth little more than face value, certain high-grade examples or coins with unique mint errors can command thousands from eager collectors.
Why This Coin Was Valuable
The 1999-P SBA dollar is significant because it was part of the final year of the series before the U.S. Mint transitioned to the Sacagawea dollar in 2000.
Although over 29 million were minted, only a fraction exist in pristine condition or with rare errors.
The thrift store find stood out due to its exceptional state of preservation and unusual characteristics identified during professional grading.
Factors That Boosted Its Value:
- Mint Mark & Year: The “P” mint mark for Philadelphia and the 1999 date made it desirable as a series-ending issue.
- Grade: Achieved an almost flawless MS68 rating from a major grading service.
- Collector Demand: SBA dollars have a dedicated collector base due to their short series and historical significance.
- Possible Error Traits: Slight planchet anomalies and crisp strike details added appeal.
Value Breakdown
| Feature | Description | Impact on Value |
|---|---|---|
| Year & Mint Mark | 1999-P, Philadelphia | Final-year mintage adds demand |
| Mintage | 29,592,000 | Generally common, but top-grade coins rare |
| Grade | MS68 (Mint State) | Premium pricing due to rarity in top condition |
| Condition | Full luster, no visible marks | Increased collector competition |
| Market Interest | High demand for SBA series | Price pushed higher at auction |
How Much Are Other 1999-P SBA Dollars Worth?
While this coin reached $4,200, the average 1999-P Susan B. Anthony Dollar in circulated condition is worth just $1 to $2. Even uncirculated examples typically sell for $10–$30 unless they are graded at the highest levels or feature dramatic mint errors.
Some rare error coins from this year, such as those struck on Sacagawea planchets, have been known to sell for $10,000 or more due to their rarity and historical importance.
Tips for Identifying a Valuable SBA Dollar
- Check the Mint Mark: Look for the “P” below the date.
- Assess Condition: Minimal wear, strong strike, and full luster boost value.
- Look for Errors: Wrong planchet strikes, double strikes, or off-center designs can be highly valuable.
- Get Professional Grading: A certified grade can dramatically increase marketability and price.
- Compare Auction Results: Research recent sales to set realistic expectations.
The Market Outlook for SBA Dollars
Interest in the Susan B. Anthony Dollar has been growing among collectors, especially for the 1979-P Wide Rim, 1981-S Type 2 Proof, and top-grade 1999-P coins.
With modern coin collecting seeing a surge in error coin demand, coins with documented provenance and exceptional condition are likely to continue appreciating in value.
The $4,200 sale of a 1999-P Susan B. Anthony Dollar proves that rare finds can still happen in unexpected places.
While most SBA dollars are common, those in exceptional condition or with significant errors can command impressive prices.
Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just starting out, it pays to check your change and thrift store finds carefully—your next discovery could be worth thousands.
FAQs
Is every 1999-P Susan B. Anthony Dollar worth thousands?
No. Only top-grade coins or rare mint errors have high market value. Most examples are worth face value to a few dollars.
How can I tell if my coin is high-grade?
A professional coin grading service will assess strike quality, luster, and imperfections to assign an accurate grade.
Can thrift stores have other rare coins?
Yes. Thrift stores, flea markets, and estate sales sometimes yield valuable coins overlooked by previous owners.